Kelly Galloup's Compara Spinner
Kelly's fly combines elements from Mike's Sparkle Dun, Craig Matthews'
Improved Sparkle Dun and his Deer Hair Spinner: Poly Yarn to represent
a trailing shuck, and as a winging material to represent the upright wings
of a dun as well as the collapsed wings of a spent spinner.
- I find Poly Yarn (or similar) is easier to work with than Comparadun /
Elk hair
- The spinner wing + comparadun style upright wing combination should make
it virtually unsinkable
- Kelly mentions substituting Poly Yarn for micro fibbet tails - less fiddly,
will improve flotation, and represents trailing shuck,
- In summary, this is a improvement / variation of a Sparkle Dun
The Compara Spinner is - in my opinion - endowed with several
'triggers':
- spent wings create star-bursts of light on the water surface which act
as the
primary approach trigger
- Upright wing maintain the
approach response
- the trailing shuck signals the
vulnerabilityof the emerging insect